On Monday, a federal judge in the U.S. dismissed a lawsuit that alleged pop superstar Taylor Swift, recently married, copied phrases from the poetry of a woman from Florida for more than a dozen of her songs.
U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon ruled that the plaintiff, Kimberly Marasco, did not provide sufficient evidence to establish that her poems were protectable or that Swift had access to them. Furthermore, it was determined that an average person would not consider the songs to be substantially similar.
Marasco represented herself in the case. In an email response, she expressed her disagreement with the ruling and indicated plans to appeal.
Attorneys for Swift and the other defendants, which include Republic Records and Universal Music Group, did not respond promptly to requests for comments.
The accusations against Swift, who is 36, involved claims that she borrowed elements from Marasco’s poetry in songs such as Down Bad and I Can Do It with a Broken Heart, both featured on Swift’s upcoming 2024 album, The Tortured Poets Department.
Judge Cannon noted that any similarities between Marasco’s works and Swift’s songs were limited to “unprotectable ideas, themes, metaphors, and isolated words.”
-
Inside Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s wedding: What we know
-
Taylor Swift, Travis Kelce marry in elaborate ceremony at NYC’s Madison Square Garden
Cannon provided several examples, including themes of facing challenges, experiencing “gaslighting,” and feeling “submerged” underwater.
The judge had previously rejected an earlier version of Marasco’s lawsuit last September.
She pointed out that the new allegations made by Marasco did not demonstrate substantial similarity, a point that the plaintiff effectively acknowledged by describing the supposed copying as “paraphrase,” “rephrase,” and involving “minor word substitutions.”
The dismissal issued on Monday was with prejudice, indicating that Marasco cannot modify her complaint. Cannon’s chambers are located in Fort Pierce, Florida.
Swift wed Travis Kelce, also 36, the renowned football player, at Madison Square Garden in Manhattan on July 3.

